Sami Zayn versus Luke Harper versus Dolph Ziggler versus Mojo Rawley versus Erick Rowan versus Jinder Mahal in a Number One Contender Match
Winner: Jinder Mahal
After the match: Renee Young interviews Jinder. Jinder says you want to boo the Majarajah. You boo because he is not the stereotypical All American. Is it because of his family wealth? It is because he speaks two languages? You Americans do not accept diversity but you have no choice but to accept Jinder Mahal as your next WWE Champion.
Randy Orton’s music plays and he makes his way onto the stage. Randy says he guesses congratulations are in order. You have won the jackpot, but your prize won’t be this title. Orton enters the ring. The only prize you have awarded yourself is an RKO from yours truly. Before he puts his hands on Jinder, he has to deal with another thorn in his side. Randy says he does not know what a House of Horrors Match is, but if it is like the last house you took him to, he will burn it down as well. Bray Wyatt appears on the TitanTron and he tells Randy he wants him to feel his pain. He wants Randy to feel his suffering. All of the agony that he has had to endure, orchestrated by your hand. Still, none of these things will compare to what you will face in his House of Horrors. You don’t understand what you are getting yourself into. You may walk into the House of Horrors as the viper, but he promises Randy he will never walk out. Never . . . RUN
Erick Rowan versus Randy Orton
They lock up and Rowan misses a punch but Orton does not miss with a kick and then he sends Rowan into the turnbuckles and punches him. Orton with a kick but Rowan with a back elbow. Rowan with punches in the corner and then he puts Randy on the turnbuckles and punches him again. Rowan goes up for a superplex but Orton with punches and he sends Rowan to the mat with head butts. Orton with an elbow to a charging Rowan and then Orton with a power slam. Orton with the Garvin Stomp. Rowan goes to the floor and Orton follows. Rowan charges at Orton but Orton moves and Rowan hits the ring steps. Orton sets for the IEDDT and he hits it. Orton looks around and he sets for the twist to the mat to set up the RKO.
The lights go out and Bray Wyatt appears. He tells Randy that he is over here. He asks if you can smell it. He says it is fear and Randy reeks of it. He says their paths will cross again. He says he is the nagging conscience of a world full of monsters. He will see Randy soon in the House of Horrors. The lights go out again and when they come back on, Rowan is on the floor and Rowan hits Orton with the ring steps. The referee calls for the bell.
Winner: Randy Orton (by disqualification)
After the match: Rowan brings Orton back into the ring and Rowan hits a full nelson slam.
Randy Orton makes his way to the ring. Randy reminds everyone about what he said if you can’t beat them join them. He says that he forgot to say that if you are going to win, beat their ass. Randy says that he proved that he is Bray’s master and Bray will never forget his name. Bray appears on the TitanTron. Bray says that Randy is the master of nothing. Make no mistake about it, their feud has just begun. Bray says he will reclaim what she said is his. He has his rematch coming, but he has something special planned for Randy. He wants to fight Randy in a different type of match. A match that will work your body as well as your mind. Bray says he will change the way you view this entire world. Light into darkness. Kindness into wrath. He says he will watch Randy cry. He will watch Randy’s soul devour itself. At the end of the night, the other will be sentenced to eternal damnation.
Bray says he wants to fight Randy in a House of Horrors match. Randy says he does not know what a House of Horrors match is, but he will accept the challenge. He tells Bray to come to the ring so he can whip his ass again. The lights go out and they come back on and Bray is standing behind Randy and he tells Randy that he is here. Wyatt with punches but Orton with a power slam. Orton is pulled to the floor by Erick Rowan in a new mask. Rowan sends Orton into the ring and they double team Orton. Luke Harper’s music plays ane he comes to the ring. Harper takes care of Rowan on the floor and then Wyatt tries to give Harper Sister Abigail, but he escapes and hits a boot. Orton and Harper stand together in the ring.
Luke Harper and Randy Orton versus Bray Wyatt and Erick Rowan
Rowan and Orton start things off and Orton avoids a clothesline and goes for an RKO but Rowan escapes. Rowan with a spinning heel kick and Orton is down. We are back and Orton moves when Wyatt charges into the corner and both men are down. Harper tags in and he clotheslines Wyatt and then he hits a running elbow. Wyatt with an Irish whip but Harper goes to the apron and punches Wyatt and hits a slingshot senton. Rowan is knocked to the floor and Wyatt is sent to the floor. Harper with a suicide dive that sends Rowan over the announce table. Wyatt with a clothesline to Harper. Rowan tags in and Wyatt with a back senton followed by a splash from Rowan for the three count.
World Title Match: Bray Wyatt vs Randy Orton
Randy comes right in with a Thesz press and starts working Wyatt over, and he quickly goes for the RKO but Wyatt bails out to the floor. Orton goes after him and continues the assault. Orton rolls Wyatt back inside but gets caught with a running headbutt from Wyatt. Wyatt does his backward arch thing in the corner and the lights go out, and a projection of grubs climbing over each other cover the mat. Orton rolls out to the floor, then runs in and Wyatt tries catching him with Sister Abigail, but Orton slips free and gets caught with a running tackle from Wyatt.
Wyatt tosses Orton out to the apron hits a diving forearm, then they go back inside where Wyatt hits a charging splash in the corner. Another back arch, and this time it’s worms in the ring. Orton goes for another RKO, but Wyatt counters to a uranage and a senton for 2. Wyatt goes for Sister Abigail again, but Orton counters to a rollup for 2, then gets his head taken off by a hard clothesline. Orton rolls out to the floor again, Wyatt tries diving off the apron at him, but Orton dropkicks him coming down. Orton picks Wyatt up, but Wyatt hits Sister Abigail into the barricade, and Orton is knocked fo ra loop. Wyatt charges him, but RKO out of nowhere on the floor. They go back in and Orton sets for the punt, but Wyatt dodges and goes for Sister Abigail, Orton counters to the over the back neckbreaker. Orton with the hanging DDT, he sets for the RKO, but runs right into Sister Abigail for 2. Wyatt does the spider walk, and now it’s roaches all over the ring. Orton hits an RKO out of nowhere, makes a cover, and we have a new champion.
Winner: Randy Orton
Bray Wyatt versus Luke Harper in a Non Title Match
Winner: Bray Wyatt
After the match: Randy Orton appears on the TitanTron and he is on ‘hallowed ground. You claim Sister Abigail made you Lord Of Lords. All seeing, all knowing, all powerful. You think you have won? As he strikes this symbol of the apocalypse, he ends Sister Abigail and seals his fate at Wrestlemania. Randy says nothing will stand in his way.
Baron Corbin versus Randy Orton
They lock up and Orton with a side head lock but Corbin with a shoulder tackle. Orton goes for an RKO but Corbin escapes and goes to the floor. Corbin returns to the ring and they lock up again. Corbin with a forearm on the break and he follows with another forearm. Orton sends Corbin to the mat and then he stomps on the hand. Orton with the Garvin stomp. Orton sends Corbin into the turnbuckles and he connects with European uppercuts. Orton punches Corbin on the turnbuckles. Orton with a back elbow and Corbin goes to the floor. Orton grabs Corbin by the hair but Corbin sends Orton into the ring post. We are back and Corbin gets a near fall. Corbin with an elbow to the collarbone and then applies a half nelson and chin lock. Orton gets to his feet and he punches Corbin but Corbin punches back. Corbin goes to the floor on an Irish whip and returns with a clothesline and he gets a near fall. Corbin punches Orton and then he has something to say to Orton. Orton with a boot and then he connects with two clotheslines and then he avoids a clothesline from Corbin. Corbin knows the power slam is coming so Corbin holds on to the ropes. Corbin goes to the floor and he comes back and runs into a power slam.
Orton with a full nelson slam and he gets a near fall. Orton sets for the IEDDT but Corbin pulls Orton to the floor. Orton sends Corbin into the ring steps and apron. Corbin is sent into the steps again. Orton wtih a kick and he hits the IEDDT as he blows a kiss to the Wrestlemania sign. Orton looks around as he gets ready to twist to the mat for the RKO. Orton pounds the mat and as he sets for the RKO, Corbin counters with Deep Six and he gets a near fall.
Orton goes to the floor and Corbin follows. Corbin goes for a shoulder tackle on the floor and Orton moves. Corbin hits the ring steps but they get back into the ring. The crowd is focused on the ramp and stage area. Dean Ambrose is on a forklift and Orton with an RKO for the three count.
Winner: Randy Orton
Backstage: Randy Orton is with Renee Young in the back and he is asked about Bray Wyatt’s comment. Randy says he does not have an answer. When he bathed himself in Sister Abigail’s ashes, that was the last thing he expected. The lights flicker and Renee knows that it is best to leave. Randy wants Bray to show himself. We see a series of people in lamb masks around Orton and Orton gets in a few shots but they eventually subdue him. Bray enters the room and he baptizes Orton. He tells Randy that he exposed his one flaw, Abigail. That one flaw will become his greatest strength. She is with him and that power lives inside of him. Purging that one fatal flaw is more than Bray could ever imagine. Bray thanks Randy and he sings.